How We Test
By Joe Sanfilippo, Editor-in-Chief · Updated November 16, 2026
The Guy’s List buys many of the products we review and uses them ourselves before we write a word. We score each product from 1 to 10 on what matters for that category, publish the bad along with the good, and tell you when a brand sent something for free. We earn affiliate commission when you buy, and that never changes a score.
How We Choose What to Test
We start with what guys are actually shopping for: products readers ask us about, brands blowing up on TikTok and Instagram, and the categories we cover every week (clothing, grooming, fitness, food and gear). Before we buy anything, we ask friends and family what they use and read real customer reviews to narrow the list. That is how our body wash roundup started: a list of recommendations, then 13 bottles in a cart.
How We Buy the Products
We buy many of the products we review with our own money, at the same price you would pay. Sometimes a brand sends us a product for free. When that happens, we say so on the page. A free product gets the same test and the same scoring as one we paid for, and plenty of free products end up with low scores.
How Long We Test For
Long enough to get past first impressions. What that looks like depends on the product:
- Grooming: each product used daily for at least a week, side by side with the others in the test. For our Native body wash review, we used five scents over four months.
- Apparel: worn and washed the way you would. We note the size we bought, our height and weight, and whether it shrank or lost its shape in the wash.
- Footwear: worn for daily use and workouts before we score comfort.
- Meals and food: each meal or product eaten and scored individually.
- Supplements: we report what is on the label, how it tastes and mixes, and the cost per serving. We do not make health claims and do not say a supplement will change how your body performs.
What We Measure
- Apparel: fit against the brand’s size chart, fabric feel, warmth, and how it holds up after washing.
- Footwear: fit, comfort over time, and durability.
- Grooming: scent, how long the scent lasts, texture, how much product you need, and price per ounce.
- Food and meals: taste, portion, macros from the label, and price per meal.
- Supplements: ingredients and dose per serving from the label, taste, mixability and price per serving.
How We Score
Every product gets a score from 1 to 10. Each roundup lists the categories behind the score. Our body wash roundup, for example, scores smell and value separately and averages them.
- 9 to 10: One of our top picks for performance and price.
- 7 to 8.9: A solid pick with a few minor drawbacks.
- 5 to 6.9: Gets the job done, with clear trade-offs.
- 3 to 4.9: Disappointing, with several noticeable flaws.
- 1 to 2.9: Falls short, even on the basics.
How We Make Money
Some links on The Guy’s List are affiliate links. If you buy through one, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That money pays for the products we buy and test.
Commission does not affect our scores or rankings, and no brand can pay for a better spot. A brand offering a bigger commission does not move up a list.
Who Writes and Tests for The Guy’s List
Every review has a real person behind it. Click any name to read their full bio.
- Joe Sanfilippo, Editor-in-Chief. Former college football player who has covered men’s fashion, fitness and supplements for about ten years.
- Beau Hayhoe. Michigan State journalism graduate and freelance men’s style writer who covers clothing and grooming.
- John Shackleton. Sports performance coach who worked with Villanova Men’s Basketball and trains professional athletes.
- Marc Megna. Former NFL player and co-owner of Anatomy Fitness.
- Chris Hogan. Former NFL wide receiver and two-time Super Bowl champion.
- Brock Hoffman. Virginia Tech alum and NFL offensive lineman.
- Tom Ottaiano, Co-Founder of The Guy’s List.
How to Reach Us With a Correction
See a price that is out of date, a dead code or a detail we got wrong? Email info@theguyslist.com with the page you were reading and what needs fixing. We review every report and update the page when we find an error.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do brands pay for placement on The Guy’s List?
No. Brands cannot pay for a better score or a higher spot in a ranking. If a brand sends us a product for free, we say so in the review. It still has to earn its place.
How does The Guy’s List make money?
Through affiliate links. When you buy through a link on our site, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Commission never changes a score or a ranking.

![The Guy’s List Logo white How We Test By Joe Sanfilippo, Editor-in-Chief · Updated November [...]](https://theguyslist.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/TheGuysList-White-1-300x55.png)